One for the Murphys

A dramatic foil is a character unlike or opposite another character in terms of their traits and actions; comparing two such characters emphasizes their differences. In what ways are Mrs. Murphy and Carley’s mother dramatic foils? What other pair or pairs of characters in the story are dramatic foils? What details regarding their characterizations support your choices?

Carley tends to put herself down, both in her interior monologue and in conversation. For example, she thinks that she’ll never be anyone’s hero and, later, that college is out of the question for her. How is Carley incorrect in her views about herself and her traits? In what scenes or situations does her maturity, empathy, and cleverness show through despite her own self-deprecating remarks? What other good traits does Carley possess that you can see through indirect characterization?

Mother-daughter relationships are complex in One for the Murphys. Compare and contrast the relationship of Carley and her mother with that of Toni and her mother. How does the relationship between Toni and her mother compare to the mother-daughter-like relationship between Carley and Mrs. Murphy? Cite at least three scenes or character reactions to develop and support each answer.